Gems O.P

A Power of Attorney (POA) grants someone the authority to make decisions on another person’s behalf. But what happens when medical decisions arise and a doctor disagrees with the attorney-in-fact’s choices? This article explores the complex interplay between medical authority and POA, specifically addressing the question: can a doctor override power of attorney?

Understanding Power of Attorney and Healthcare Decisions

A POA is a legal document that designates an agent, also known as an attorney-in-fact, to act on behalf of another person, the principal. This authority can encompass financial matters, legal affairs, and, importantly, healthcare decisions. A durable power of attorney for healthcare specifically addresses medical choices and remains effective even if the principal becomes incapacitated. This allows the appointed agent to make critical healthcare decisions, ensuring the principal’s wishes are respected when they can no longer communicate them. However, the interaction between a doctor’s medical judgment and a POA isn’t always straightforward.

When a Doctor Might Question a Power of Attorney’s Decision

While a POA grants significant authority, it doesn’t provide absolute power. Doctors are bound by their medical ethics and professional judgment. They have a duty to provide the best possible care for their patients. This can create tension if the attorney-in-fact’s decision seems contrary to the patient’s best interests. Several scenarios can lead to such conflicts:

• Decisions Against Medical Advice: If the attorney-in-fact insists on a course of action that the doctor believes is harmful or ineffective, the doctor may question the decision. This might involve refusing to perform a procedure or administering a specific treatment.
• Suspected Abuse or Neglect: If the doctor suspects the attorney-in-fact is making decisions based on their own interests rather than the patient’s well-being, they are obligated to investigate and potentially report their concerns to the appropriate authorities.
• Questionable Interpretation of the Principal’s Wishes: The POA should outline the principal’s healthcare preferences. If the attorney-in-fact’s decisions seem to deviate significantly from these documented wishes, the doctor might raise concerns.
• Unclear or Conflicting Directives in the POA: Sometimes, the POA itself might contain ambiguities or contradictory instructions. In such cases, the doctor might seek clarification from the attorney-in-fact or legal counsel.

Can a Doctor Legally Override a Power of Attorney?

The answer is complex and depends on the specific circumstances. A doctor cannot unilaterally override a valid POA. However, they can challenge the attorney-in-fact’s decisions through various channels. They can:

• Seek a second medical opinion: This can help determine whether the proposed treatment is genuinely in the patient’s best interest.
• Consult with the hospital’s ethics committee: This committee can provide guidance on complex ethical dilemmas in healthcare.
• Petition the court for guardianship or conservatorship: If there are serious concerns about the attorney-in-fact’s actions, the doctor or concerned family members can petition the court to appoint a guardian or conservator to make decisions for the patient.

Protecting the Patient’s Best Interests

Ultimately, the goal is to protect the patient’s well-being. Open communication between the doctor, the attorney-in-fact, and other relevant parties is crucial.

“Clear communication and documentation of the patient’s wishes are essential to avoid conflicts between medical professionals and those holding power of attorney.” – Nguyen Thi Minh Anh, Healthcare Attorney at Lodeza Law Firm.

It is essential to establish a clear understanding of the patient’s wishes and the scope of the POA. This can help minimize disagreements and ensure that the patient receives the appropriate care.

Conclusion

The question of whether a doctor can override a power of attorney is not easily answered with a simple yes or no. While doctors cannot directly overrule a valid POA, they have avenues to address concerns and ensure the patient’s best interests are protected. Open communication, clear documentation, and a thorough understanding of the patient’s wishes are crucial to navigating these complex situations. If you are facing challenges with a power of attorney in a medical context, seeking legal counsel is advisable.

“A well-drafted power of attorney can help prevent future disputes and ensure that your healthcare wishes are respected.” – Tran Van Tuan, Senior Partner at Lodeza Law Firm.

FAQ

1. What is a durable power of attorney for healthcare? A durable power of attorney for healthcare allows a designated person to make medical decisions on your behalf if you become incapacitated.
2. Who can be an attorney-in-fact? Any competent adult can be designated as an attorney-in-fact.
3. What are the limitations of a power of attorney? A POA doesn’t grant unlimited power. The attorney-in-fact must act in the principal’s best interests and within the scope of the POA.
4. What should I do if I suspect abuse or neglect by an attorney-in-fact? Contact the appropriate authorities, such as adult protective services or the police.
5. Can I revoke a power of attorney? Yes, you can revoke a POA as long as you are mentally competent.
6. What happens if a doctor disagrees with the attorney-in-fact? The doctor can seek a second opinion, consult with the hospital’s ethics committee, or petition the court for guardianship or conservatorship.
7. Where can I get help with creating a power of attorney? Consult with an experienced attorney to ensure your POA is properly drafted and reflects your wishes.